No fee unless we recoverHome & hospital visits

Tools

C&R or Stipulations?

A Compromise and Release closes future medical care for good. Stipulations keeps it open and preserves the § 5410 right to reopen, which runs from the injury.

Free, no obligationEnglish, Español, 한국어

On this page

This is the most consequential decision most injured workers make, and it is usually explained to them in one sentence at a settlement conference.

They are not the big and small versions of the same thing.

The permanent disabilityPD Permanent Disability. Compensation for lasting impairment. A different and much lower weekly rate — 2026 maximum $290/week. indemnity is the same figure under both. What differs is everything around it.

The trade, in one table

What differsCompromise & ReleaseStipulations with Request for Award
How you are paidOne lump sumThe same indemnity, over the weeks
Future medical careClosed. For ever.Stays open for this injury
Right to reopenGiven upKept — Labor Code § 5410
If you get worseNothing furtherYou can petition
MedicareA set-aside is usually requiredUsually not an issue

The clock people get wrong

Labor Code § 5410:

“Nothing in this chapter shall bar the right of any injured worker to institute proceedings for the collection of compensation within five years after the date of the injury upon the ground that the original injury has caused new and further disability.”

Five years from the date of the injury. Not from the award.

That distinction decides how much the Stipulations column is actually worth. A worker settling four years after the injury is preserving one year of a five-year right, not five — and the tool above says which date yours ends on, because a right with eight months left in it is a different thing from a right with four years left.

What “future medical stays open” is worth

It is the part of the case with no ceiling. A future surgery, a series of injections, a spinal cord stimulator, or a lifetime of medication is routinely worth more than the indemnity — and a Compromise and ReleaseC&R — Compromise and Release A lump sum that closes future medical treatment permanently. moves all of it from the carrier to you, permanently.

The document that decides this is not a settlement document. It is your treating physician saying, in writing, what care they expect over the next ten years. Get that before you decide, not after. What future medical covers.

Medicare, and why a C&R can take months

Where you are a Medicare beneficiary or reasonably expect to be within 30 months, a Workers’ Compensation Medicare Set-AsideMSA — Medicare Set-Aside Funds allocated for future injury-related care where Medicare’s interest is involved. CMS reviews above $25,000 for current beneficiaries, or $250,000 with enrollment expected within 30 months. enters the picture. CMS reviews one where the settlement exceeds $25,000 for a current beneficiary, or $250,000 where enrolment is reasonably expected within 30 months.

Those are CMS review thresholds, not legal safe harbours. Medicare’s interest has to be considered whether or not a threshold is crossed. Practically: expect the set-aside to add months, and expect part of the money to be restricted to medical use.

Three things the table does not show

What comes off the top. Medical liens, an EDD lien, a child support lien, and credit for benefits already paid. What comes out.

Attorney fees are approved, not charged. In workers’ compensation the fee is set or approved by the Appeals Board. What it costs.

Whether anyone other than your employer was involved. That is a separate claim under Labor Code § 3852(a), it pays for pain and suffering, and settling the compensation case does not settle it. The overlap.


There is no right answer in the abstract. A C&R is right for some people and wrong for others. What this page is for is making sure you know what is being traded before somebody asks you to sign.

Sources

Labor Code § 5410§ 4658§ 4453§ 4906§ 3852CMS WCMSA Reference Guide

General information about California law, not legal advice about your case.

Rate figures carry the effective date that governs them. Temporary disability is set by date of injury; medical mileage by date of travel.

Reviewed by Jamey Teitell, Partner & Trial Attorney · Last reviewed

Law Offices of Solov & Teitell, APC · (213) 380-9310

Printed from https://www.solovteitell.com/resources/settlement-comparator/ · Last reviewed

A SHORT CALL COSTS NOTHING

Tell us what happened

A short call costs nothing and commits you to nothing. No fee unless we recover, and you are not responsible for costs we advance if there is no recovery. Free consultation in English, Spanish, or Korean.

CALL US · WE CALL BACK(213) 380-9310Free case review